 | Percy Talbott |
 | Hannah Ferguson |
 | Shelby Goddard |
 | Nahum Goddard |
 | Joe Sperling |
 | Sheriff Gary Walsh |
 | Johnny B. / Eli |
Effy Katshaw | |
Rebecca Goddard | |
Molly Goddard | |
Molly Goddard | |
 | Meeshack Boggs |
Jolene | |
Stuart | |
Customer #1 | |
Neighbor | |
Town member #2 | |
Deputy | |
Clare | |
Aaron Sperling | |
Customer #2 | |
Customer #3 | |
Woman at Bar | |
Man at Bar | |
 | Clare (voice) |
(voice) | |
(voice) | |
(voice) | |
 | (voice) |
(voice) (as Gracie Moore) | |
Grill Regular | |
Restaurant Patron / Church Member |